Member's Mark High Protein Shakes

Latest four-week snapshot through 2026-08-13 · 2 waves. Use the controls above to change the window.

Protein Shakes (RTD) · 2 waves · n=144 answers, pooled

By assistant

How often each assistant brings the brand up in recommendation answers.

Share of recommendations over time

Wave-by-wave share of recommendation answers that named this brand.

What they call it

Recurring descriptions in the assistants' own words, grouped by theme.

• 30g protein ×3

  “* **The Nutrition:** 30g protein, 160 calories, 1g sugar.”

• 120 calories per serving ×2

  “Premier Protein is loved for its high protein-to-calorie ratio, offering **30g of protein, 160 calories, and only 1g of sugar** per shake.”

• affordable pricing ×2

  “Many reviewers actually prefer the taste of the Member's Mark chocolate over name brands, and it is significantly cheaper than buying Premier Protein bulk cases.”

• identical macros ×2

  “* **The Macros:** 30g protein, 160 calories, 1g sugar, 3g fat (identical to Premier).”

• 1 g sugar ×1

  “If you love the convenience and nutritional profile of Premier Protein shakes (30g protein, 160 calories, 1g sugar) but want to cut down on costs, there are several excellent alternatives.”

• 15% to 16% cheaper ×1

  “* **Why it’s cheaper:** On a price-per-gram-of-protein basis, Member's Mark is about **15% to 16% cheaper** than Premier Protein.”

• almost exact clone ×1

  “This is almost an exact clone of Premier Protein. Many reviewers actually prefer the taste of the Member's Mark chocolate over name brands, and it is significantly cheaper than buying Premier Protein bulk cases.”

• budget-friendly ×1

  “* **The Verdict:** Many budget-conscious shoppers swear these are actually made by Premier Protein due to the identical ingredients and taste profile.”

• closest dupe on the market ×1

  “* **The Scoop:** This is widely considered the closest dupe on the market, with some consumers speculating they are manufactured by the same parent company.”

• highly-rated ultra-filtered milk version ×1

  “Another nutrition-match clone. It is perfect if you already have a Sam's Club membership. They also carry a highly-rated "Ultra-Filtered Milk" version.”

In their words

6 exact quoted mentions in this snapshot, grouped by coded tone.

What they recommend

“This is almost an exact clone of Premier Protein. Many reviewers actually prefer the taste of the Member's Mark chocolate over name brands, and it is significantly cheaper than buying Premier Protein bulk cases.”

“This is widely considered the closest dupe on the market, with some consumers speculating they are manufactured by the same parent company. It has identical macros: 30g protein, 160 calories, 3g fat, and 1g sugar.”

“~$26 for an 18-pack (~$1.44 per shake)”

“Sam's Club offers an ultra-filtered milk protein shake that closely mimics top-tier brands like Fairlife and Premier Protein for a fraction of the cost.”

“On a price-per-gram-of-protein basis, Member's Mark is about **15% to 16% cheaper** than Premier Protein. Some users actually prefer the taste, suspecting they might even be produced by the same parent manufacturer.”

The substitution map

Which competitors assistants suggest when shoppers ask for something cheaper.

Where this comes from

2 of 6 mentions appear alongside an identifiable web citation. Citation does not establish causation.

Where they send you

Stores and sites assistants name as places to buy this brand.

Method: fixed shopper questions asked repeatedly to Claude, OpenAI GPT and Gemini with web search on. Shares are the percentage of recommendation answers mentioning the brand. Quotes are AI outputs; full transcripts are kept as receipts.